I'm sure that for my grandmother it was her something blue. Except I already have my blue taken care of with my shoes. But even if I didn't already have the shoes, I think the garter has to be considered my something old. And hopefully I'm able to hand it down to my future daughter for her something old as well.
To put a small kink in this plan, we're planning on doing a garter toss, and there's no way I'm tossing this. Instead I plan on buying a cheap throw away garter that we can use for the sole purpose of the toss. I don't know if it makes sense to wear both through the day or maybe change garter just before the ceremony. And I've never worn a garter before, so it's not like I have any point of reference as to what it's like wearing a single garter or instead two.
Do you think I should wear both my grandma's & my throw garter throughout the day or just one at a time? And did anyone else have a garter to keep and one to toss?